Download this talk
*
*
*
*
* Video to desktop (Zipped MP4)
* Video to iTunes (MP4)
*
Share this talk
* Email to a friend »
*
Post to Digg or
* Embed this video
* Link to this talk
Discuss this talk: The science of scent ( Luca Turin )
Sign in to add comments or Join (It’s free and fast!)
Jeffrey Soreff November 8 2008
The explanation of the mechanism of smell seems somewhat implausible, but, yes, there are a variety of ways one could make a nanoscale IR spectrometer. Another option would be to look for resonant energy transfer, not between a tunnelling electron, but between a vibrational excitation in another molecule and the test molecule.
One skeptical note: I’ve handled heavy water, and never noticed an odor. If this theory is right, it should smell very different from the odorless background of normal water.
One application note: If the theory is right, there should be a huge range of deuterated compounds with distinct smells... and there would be a wide choice of very safe ones.
Tom Kraemer November 7 2008
What a wonderful explanation of scent and our sense of smell. Thank you for a profound insight. You’ve changed my understanding of my formerly least appreciated sense!
Rylan Grayston November 7 2008
I think some homeopathic practitioners are running into a very similar situation as you.
In that they get results that they cannot fully explain the workings of.
In the past I often found myself scoffing at the explanations I have heard. The use of words like energy flow to describe how a massage works has been
hard for me to respond too. I have discovered that when some one makes no scene at all they are often using a hole different set of definitions than I know of. For example my dictionary has 6 distinct definitions for plasma. How may dose yours have and which are you using?
Your story is a great example of how
-some one with an explanation that seems obvious and correct with no results
is of no more value than
-someone with concrete results that support a seemingly ridiculous explanation.
Its very entertaining to hear the later come together.
Thanks for explaining how the hard evidence implies that the human body can detect molecular vibration and interpret it as smell.
ps I laughed at the biologist vs physicist joke e mediately, common tedsters lighten up
that was elegantly place hummor!
cheers!
Showing page 1 of 1 (3 total comments)
* « Previous
* 1
* Next »
About this talk
What’s the science behind a sublime perfume? With charm and precision, biophysicist Luca Turin explains the molecular makeup — and the art — of a scent.
1 view
48
9
5 months ago 00:24:22 3
EUROVISION SONG CONTEST 2022 • Behind the Scenes • Lighting & Stage Design, Audio
9 months ago 01:21:18 1
La Sábana Santa a la luz de la ciencia | Jorge Manuel Rodríguez
9 months ago 00:04:03 1
HUMBERTO TOZZI - TE AMO
10 months ago 00:08:42 18
Billy Cobham + Tullio De Piscopo Drum duel pt 1 HD VERSION
1 year ago 00:38:28 1
Ural - Psychoverse (Full Album, 2023)
1 year ago 00:07:15 11
(128Kbps) Kai Djuric - Calma Apparente (Luca Lala Main Mix) [2Elle Records]
1 year ago 00:20:50 1
🇬🇧 Core i5-10400 vs Core i9-9900k QQLS for gaming, testing 22 games, 1080p, RX 6800XT, Ryzen 5 5600X
2 years ago 00:02:55 1
LUM!X feat. Pia Maria - Halo - Austria 🇦🇹 - Official Music Video - Eurovision 2022
2 years ago 00:09:49 1
1965 Maserati Mistral Coupe: End of an Era
2 years ago 00:02:56 1
NEROARGENTO - Land Of Silence ft. Vicio (OFFICIAL MUSIC VIDEO)
3 years ago 00:19:49 2
Re-Animated - Re-Animated (EP, 2022)
3 years ago 00:01:42 4
Perfume History: L’Eau de la Reine de Hongrie (Hungary Water)
3 years ago 00:00:40 4
Turin contre le pass sanitaire
3 years ago 00:05:19 26
ТУРИН MITO 2021 Torino - Tonalità francese
3 years ago 00:25:18 1
Gaetano Pugnani (1731-1798) - Concerto in re maggiore per due violini
4 years ago 00:04:31 1
DIONYSIAN - Bleeder {At The End of The Day} - (Official Video)
4 years ago 00:31:26 12
The Absolute End Of The World - Somewhere Else (2021) (Full Album Premiere)
4 years ago 00:15:54 1
Luca Turin: The science of scent
4 years ago 00:04:10 1
The Russian-Italian Organ Duo plays “Take on me“ by A-ha
5 years ago 00:02:36 2
The Russian-Italian Organ Duo plays “Tango Étude no. 5“ by Astor Piazzolla (arr. by Luca Massaglia)
5 years ago 00:08:04 12
Film Camera Battle #2 | Yashica T4 vs Olympus AF 10 Super
5 years ago 00:02:43 1
The Russian-Italian Organ Duo plays “Dank sei dir, Vater“ (Samba) by Liselotte Kunkel
5 years ago 00:08:04 2
The Russian-Italian Organ Duo plays “Passacaglia“ by Johan-Magnus Sjöberg
5 years ago 00:02:08 2
The Russian-Italian Organ Duo plays “Sortie française - Katiusha“ by Grimoaldo Macchia