Study gurus promote active recall and spaced repetition to maximize learning. But is it all its cracked up to be? In the brain, retrieval and encoding processes interact to produce learning. The trick is doing them right.
01:17 Our brain’s memory systems
02:38 Justin’s beef with active recall
03:29 Spaced repetition systems, “active recall”, and spaced retrieval practice
04:35 Why flashcard systems kind of suck
05:12 Justin’s recommendation
05:35 What are “desirable difficulties”?
07:03 The alternatives to flashcards
08:35 A good question to ask yourself when studying
10:02 An example study comparing elaborative encoding to retrieval practice
11:25 A true statement
Here are some of my other videos which are relevant to the discussion:
How forgetting works:
Free recall demo:
Questions about free recall answered:
Example of encoding from reading using organization:
What researchers knew in 1979:
Advice about learning on your own:
Other myths about learning:
Desirable difficulties: (my first youtube video!)
Flashcards:
Interleaving:
Sign up to my email newsletter, Avoiding Folly, here:
To read more about retrieval practice, check out:
Justin Sung’s video on retrieval:
Justin Sung’s video on encoding:
The pro baseball footage is from:
REFERENCES
The article I showed in the video comparing elaborative encoding to retrieval practice is:
Karpicke, J. D., & Blunt, J. R. (2011). Retrieval practice produces more learning than elaborative studying with concept mapping. Science, 331(6018), 772-775.
Below, one of the classic pieces on retrieval. It’s really an illustration of why you shouldn’t just stop trying to remember something just because you have successfully recalled it in the past:
Karpicke, J. D., & Roediger III, H. L. (2008). The critical importance of retrieval for learning. science, 319(5865), 966-968.
This is a meta-analysis on the testing effect, which I haven’t read in-depth lately, but is worth checking out if you’re into this stuff:
Rowland, C. A. (2014). The effect of testing versus restudy on retention: a meta-analytic review of the testing effect. Psychological bulletin, 140(6), 1432.
There’s quite a bit of support for the idea that you want to be operating at a “high level“ (e.g., synthesizing, applying, critiquing) early in the game. It’s not like you need to learn all these rote facts first. A point that Justin makes eloquently in his video on encoding. The piece below is a great discussion of that.
Agarwal, P. K. (2019). Retrieval practice & Bloom’s taxonomy: Do students need fact knowledge before higher order learning?. Journal of Educational Psychology, 111(2), 189.
Some have argued that retrieval is only good for simple materials (like remembering new vocabulary words) and not complex materials (like understanding how Newtonian physics works). Although many of the early studies do focus on “simple“ materials, there’s plenty of studies that establish the effect of retrieval is just as strong for complex materials.
Karpicke, J. D., & Aue, W. R. (2015). The testing effect is alive and well with complex materials. Educational Psychology Review, 27(2), 317-326.
1 view
234
53
1 week ago 00:04:32 1
Hacktivist - Forgot About H [Dr Dre and Eminem Cover] Ft Black Cat Bill Of Dropout Kings
1 week ago 00:02:23 1
5 Steps to Learn Juggling / Non-Standard Method How to Juggle
1 week ago 00:09:02 1
How Would a Katana Swordmaster Fight with a Buckler?
1 week ago 00:11:44 1
Soldier Food Then VS Now
1 week ago 02:06:36 1
Esta Canción Es Para Ti Si Estás Cansado - Flauta Curativos Tibetanos, Elimina Estrés, Ansiedad
1 week ago 01:00:01 1
No anxiety can change your future | Stoic Ambience (Playlist)
1 week ago 00:30:38 3
Indian student in Russia: syrniki, travelling and physics (MEPhI-Rosatom)
1 week ago 01:57:44 1
Slipknot | 22 Songs on Piano | Relaxing Version ♫ Music to Study/Work
1 week ago 00:11:11 1
my paris studio (empty apartment tour)
1 week ago 00:23:28 1
Giuliani Complete.
1 week ago 01:00:01 1
Tibet - Healing Ethereal Ambient Meditation - Relaxing Sleep Ambient Music
1 week ago 00:19:04 1
Henri-Joseph Rigel (1741-1799): Sonata in B-flat Major ()
1 week ago 00:02:07 1
The Solo That Almost Broke My Sax! We Turned The Funk Dial All The Way Up To 11
1 week ago 00:06:16 1
Это еще хуже сахара...😲 Растительное масло❌
1 week ago 00:16:59 1
The Fastest Way to Improve Your Art in 1 Hour
1 week ago 00:06:41 1
We shouldn’t use labels like “Alternative” and “Conventional” Medicine
1 week ago 00:03:36 1
A Fascinating Study Of Orchids Part 7 - Pests and Diseases
1 week ago 00:03:09 1
Scott Fisher - Winnie (Lyrics cc)
1 week ago 00:10:50 1
Law & Economics Only? We Asked People in Paris What They Studied | Easy French 203
1 week ago 00:04:05 1
The Story of Swooshman | Destroy: Never E2 | Nike
1 week ago 01:00:01 4
Calm Before the Storm Ambience | Deep Rolling Thunder in Distance | Warm, Balmy and Windy | 1 HOUR
1 week ago 00:15:38 1
Canadian Hate Science is COMING to U.S. and we MUST STOP IT | Redacted w Natali and Clayton Morris
1 week ago 00:25:12 1
❤ 2023 DIMASH HIGHLIGHTS • Talks / Interviews
1 week ago 02:00:51 1
If This Video Appears In Your Life, All The Miracle Will Come - Tibetan Flute Sound Brings Good Luck