The One That Got Away // B & S

Another “in my headcanon Blaine and Sam were together“ video. Blaine sees Sam at Rachel’s party, and his feelings all start coming back, hard (pretend that Sam and Quinn got back together after the party or something, or Sam and Santana were just making out because they were drunk). He visits Sam at McKinley and they go to get coffee, where Sam admits that he’s dating Quinn, a girl. Blaine is devastated, and tries to convince Sam he’s lying to himself. Sam tells him he’s not gay, but starts really thinking about all the times he and Blaine had and how much he enjoyed his life. Blaine visits him again at McKinley, causing Quinn to become suspicious, but Sam assures her he loves her, but he knows that he’s lying now. When he imagines Blaine while he’s kissing Quinn, he realizes that the fair thing to do is break up with her and tell her the truth. Rachel overhears, and tells Sam that it’s okay to be who he is, while Karofsky finds out and verbally abuses him. This sends Sam