An Appellate Court Will Not Change a Plea Contract
INVITED ERROR MAKES SENTENCE REMAIN UNCHANGED
Post 4865
Travis Darrell Gentry pled guilty to insurance fraud by presenting to insurer or person false or altered statement material to insurance, Idaho Code § 41-293(1)(c). Pursuant to a plea agreement, in exchange for his guilty plea, additional charges were dismissed. In State Of Idaho v. Travis Darrell Gentry, No. 51304, Court of Appeals of Idaho (August 21, 2024) the issue was resolved.
As part of the plea agreement, both parties recommended a sentence of three years, with a minimum period of incarceration of one year, and three years of probation. The district court followed the recommendation and imposed a unified sentence of three years, with a minimum period of incarceration of one year, suspended the sentence, and placed Gentry on a term of probation for three years.
Mindful that he received the sentence that he requested, Gentry appealed contending that his sentence is excessive.
ANALYSIS
Although Gentry received the sentence he asked for, he asserts that the district court abused its discretion by imposing an excessive sentence.
The doctrine of invited error applies to estop a party from asserting an error when his or her own conduct induces the commission of the error. One may not complain of errors one has consented to or acquiesced in. This doctrine applies to sentencing decisions as well as rulings made during trial.
Therefore, because Gentry received the sentence he requested, he may not complain that the district court abused its discretion in sentencing. Accordingly, the judgment of conviction and sentence are affirmed.
ZALMA OPINION
Insurance criminals are narcissists. They think they can convince anyone of anything. Mr. Gentry was wrong. He agreed to a sentence in exchange for the state dropping some of the charges, he had nothing to complain about but did so anyway. The court made him stand by his agreement even if it was more than was appropriate it was the deal he made and he was required to serve the time. It takes a great deal of gall to try to set aside an agreement made between Gentry, his lawyer, the prosecutor and the trial judge. He will serve the time.
(c) 2024 Barry Zalma & ClaimSchool, Inc.
Please tell your friends and colleagues about this blog and the videos and let them subscribe to the blog and the videos.
Subscribe to my substack at
Go to X @bzalma; Go to @c/1653419?s=01; Go to Barry Zalma videos at at Go to Barry Zalma on YouTube-
Go to the Insurance Claims Library –
1 view
47
13
4 days ago 01:07:30 1
MICHEL DOURTHE : Médium
4 weeks ago 00:11:44 1
Apple CEO’s High Stake Visit To China For Apology & Request To Market Share
4 weeks ago 00:08:05 3
URSULA VON DER LEYEN verliert die Oberhand? VICTOR ORBANS Angriff sorgt für Aufsehen!
4 weeks ago 00:22:53 1
Montpellier: une femme de 25 ans meurt d’une méningite aiguë après de multiples appels au Samu
4 weeks ago 00:04:28 1
Exclusive inside Apple’s audio lab where the company is taking on hearing loss
4 weeks ago 01:58:10 1
La Vérité en Questions - Dr Yves Couvreur : 1 an de recueil des témoignages de ciblés
4 weeks ago 00:05:52 1
iPad Mini 2024 Teardown - Did Apple Fix Jelly Scrolling?
4 weeks ago 11:55:01 1
I’ll have an apple and oatmeal! I haven’t had sugar in a year! No flour! No sugar! Gluten free
4 weeks ago 00:04:17 4
Vallmo — Othem (OFFICIAL MUSIC VIDEO)
4 weeks ago 00:00:10 1
Impressive apple pressing.
4 weeks ago 00:07:27 1
Invraisemblable : une cité HLM à l’abandon depuis 20 ans
4 weeks ago 00:04:26 1
1988 : Joseph est un guérisseur hors du commun 🧙♂️ | INA Officiel
4 weeks ago 00:09:53 1
Apple Selling iPhone 16 At Discounted Price in China, But No One Is Buying!
1 month ago 01:31:23 1
ABDUCTIONS & HYPNOSES RÉGRESSIVES
1 month ago 00:49:29 1
Daniel Meurois sur son livre “Sous le voile de Meryem“
1 month ago 01:58:41 1
Puff Daddy : un scandale peut en cacher un autre...
1 month ago 00:03:38 3
🚨 APPEL du Pr Henri Joyeux
1 month ago 00:53:20 1
En guerre(s) pour l’Algérie (1/6) | Crépuscule colonial | ARTE
1 month ago 00:01:06 1
Can I Connect My Bluetooth Hearing Aids to Both Apple and Android Devices? | Aanvii Hearing
1 month ago 00:02:01 1
An Apple a Day | Popular Nursery Rhymes by KidsCamp