Reframing the Narrative: 5 Main Points to Understand the Palestine-Israel Crisis & 2 Key Refutations
Reframing the Narrative: 5 Key Points to Understand the Palestine-Israel Crisis
00:00 Introduction
02:51 Refuting two false arguments
03:23 Refuting argument 1: “Hamas must be condemned“ (with no condemnation of Israel’s crimes)
04:38 Refuting argument 2: “Israel has a right to defend itself“
06:20 Summarising the 5 key points
08:45 Key point 1: Israel’s apartheid, illegal occupation and murder for over 70 years
12:39 Thought experiment: The French occupation of London
20:24 Key point 2: Over 130 Palestinian children were killed between 2021 and 2023 prior to October 7, where was the outrage?
24:17 Key point 3: Gaza has been an open air prison and has been described as “unliveable“, “degrading“ and “peverse“
27:52 Key point 4: Notwithstanding Hamas and Islamic Jihad as procribed groups other factions have legal justification to resist occupation
30:44 Key point 5: Israel’s response is not proportionate
30:58 Thought experiment: Your neighbour occupying your village and killing your family
32:51 Conclusion
References and further reading:
Filiu, J-P. (2014). The Twelve Wars on Gaza. Journal of Palestinian Studies, 44(1), pp. 52-60.
Defence for Children International. (February 2012). Recruitment and Use of Palestinian Children in Armed Conflict. Defence for Children International Palestine Section.
Loewenstein, A. (2023). The Palestine Laboratory: How Israel exports the technology of Occupation around the World. London: Verso.
Mearsheimer, John J.; Stephen M Walt. The Israel Lobby and US Foreign Policy (Kindle Locations 7012-15240). Penguin Books Ltd. Kindle Edition.
Dugard, J. & Reynolds, J. (2013). Apartheid, International Law, and the Occupied Palestinian Territory. The European Journal of International Law, 24(3).
1125/
Selby, J., Daoust, G., & Hofmann, C. (2022). Divided Environments: An International Political Ecology of Climate Change, Water and Security. Cambridge University Press.
Pappe, I. (2006) The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine. One World: Oxford.
Masalha, N. (2018) Palestine: A Four Thousand Year History. Zed Books.
1 view
5
0
3 weeks ago 00:14:30 1
‘It’s time we knew the TRUTH!’ | Calls to end immigration ‘COVER UP’ as key data hidden from public
4 weeks ago 00:02:34 1
Paving the Way to TRUMPSARA
4 weeks ago 00:00:00 1
EXCLUSIF : PRÉSENT AU SOMMET DES BRICS À KAZAN, IL RÉVÈLE TOUT ! | FRÉDÉRIC AIGOUY | GPTV
4 weeks ago 00:13:10 1
VIOLENT PRAYERS AGAINST WITCHES & AGENTS OF SATAN
4 weeks ago 00:45:42 1
“Money Is Deranging Politics“ Elon’s Musk, North Korea, BRICS, Tim Pool, AI, Claude | Tom’s Trending
4 weeks ago 00:09:13 1
The disabled Ukrainians facing a lifetime of mistreatment and abuse – BBC News
4 weeks ago 01:32:21 1
OLIGARCHIE : LES SECRETS DE L’ALLIANCE MACRON-ARNAULT ! | SERGE FEDERBUSCH | GÉOPOLITIQUE PROFONDE
4 weeks ago 00:57:32 1
Donald Trump | This Past Weekend w/ Theo Von #526
4 weeks ago 00:08:45 1
Paul McCartney Reflects Why The Beatles Reunion Failed!! | tribuune.
4 weeks ago 00:02:13 1
SERVANT OF THE PEOPLE | SERVANT OF THE PEOPLE | Trailer | English Subtitles |2016
4 weeks ago 00:34:10 8
LES MONDIALISTES VEULENT FAIRE DISPARAÎTRE LA FAMILLE TRADITIONNELLE ! | GPTV INTERVIEW
4 weeks ago 00:51:26 2
MAYDAY VOL. II [FULL ALBUM 56:26 MIN] 1993 “FORWARD EVER - BACKWARD NEVER“ HD HQ HIGH QUALITY
4 weeks ago 00:00:39 1
#Pope #Francis #Concludes #Synod #Without #Major #Reforms for #Women’s #Role in #Catholic #Church
4 weeks ago 01:19:47 1
Memmingen, Germany Walking tour [4K].
1 month ago 00:10:21 1
When Idiots Play: Driving Games #2
1 month ago 00:01:42 7
THE WHIP - Parliament Heist Movie | Official UK Trailer
1 month ago 00:16:40 1
Neville Chamberlain beyond Munich: The real story
1 month ago 00:04:01 1
Playing Bach on a 16th-century Italian Villa
1 month ago 02:18:20 1
Стамбул. Путешествие с Тамарой Эйдельман.
1 month ago 00:02:32 1
Making History
1 month ago 00:44:46 1
What Ezekiel WARNED About Is Happening Right NOW! - Bible Study
1 month ago 01:08:46 1
The EU Could Die (If It Fails To Reform)
1 month ago 00:33:19 1
We Explored The Haunted Lyman School For Boys In Massachusetts Abandoned For Over 50 Years!